What kind of video games should I get?

Im kinda picky when It comes to video games and sometimes its hard to find ones I like. Lets just start with things I don't like. I don't like games where there are levels where the goal is basically the same(like arcade games), I don't like games without a goals or stories(they have to have stories, I don't like platform games like mario, or old games like the first 3 resident evil games where the controls make your characters walk like robots and the voice acting is over dramatic(example first resident evil game) or when the graphics suck. I don't like horror games that are too intense like when I got resident evil 4 wii edition it took months for me to finally get the courage to play it(I like it now but sometimes it will get so intense, scary, and hard that I give up for the longest time and get too scared to want to play it again) I don't like driving games first of all because I SUCK at them and second of all they are boring, I don't like first person point of view games because I like to see my surroundings, and I cant play E rated games unless you ABSOLUTELY know it is hard in a certain way(example kingdom hearts). I have a playstation 2, a wii, and a ds(I do not have many ds games because they don have many t rated or m rated games or at least games that don't bore me to tears because of how childish the title sounds) I like a challenge so a game with a few mysteries or puzzles would be nice(like Agatha Christie Then There Were None or Tomb Raider games). Like I said they have to have stories or even missions a good example is Alias I love that game. I also like life games like sims(NOT MY SIMS, SIMS) or innocents life. I do have ultimate alliance but its not exactly my favorite because it has too much action and I don't really like the graphics. I love resident evil 4 and tomb raiders graphics they are so realistic. Im also getting an xbox 360 for christmas so a few christmas list games wouldn't hurt. I like mysteries like L.A. Noire(which I do not have but would love to have) or spy games like Alias or 24 the game. I think that about sums it up so if you have any suggestions please let me know.